Entries in a spiritual journal are rarely the last word on the topic they are discussing. By their very nature they are addressing deep matters of the soul, which often frustratingly defy clear expression in words. But the very effort of trying can bring a greater degree of clarity. Attempting to say out-loud, whether to a journal or to another person who is really listening, what is whirling around inside often produces real insight. And in this process nothing is sacred except the practice of devastating honesty. Consistency does not matter, only truth.
The following entry should be seen in this light. It reflects a work in progress.
I recently played in a chess tournament for the first time in many years. In fact, it was the first time I had played chess at all for many years. It was a bit of a shock in a number of ways.
It is one of the world’s best-kept secrets that once upon a time I was a pretty good player, to the extent that for a while I devoted myself to chess on a professional basis. Eventually, however, I drifted away from the game. I realised that I actually didn’t enjoy chess itself, but the very temporary thrill of winning – which is a sure-fire recipe for suffering.
Recently the thought came to mind of making a comeback. I am sure that a strand of this impulse was the fact that it is very difficult to give-up something that one is good at. In chess I was “somebody”. But I also wondered if, after many years of spiritual enquiry and practice, I would be able to play the game in a different way. Perhaps I would be able to concentrate on the creative side of the game (like mathematics, chess is capable of great beauty) rather than the competitive.
So I entered a tournament being held near to where I live.
Things did not go well.
In fact, I had my worst ever result in a tournament of this type. Even when starting out as a teenager, I never scored so poorly. It was a chastening experience. More than that, I still did not enjoy the game itself. I told my wife that entering the tournament had resolved the question in my mind – I would not be playing again.
But then something strange happened. Over the next few days I found myself drawn once more to the idea of playing, despite what had happened. I began to rationalize about how if I just did a bit of work, I could get back to my previous standard; how I could then play creatively rather competitively; and how it must be right to express a talent that one has been given.
All those years of spiritual enquiry and practice have, however, taught me to be suspicious of such rationalizations. The mind has many veils. So I have been trying to look deeper to see where this impulse is coming from.
Part of it is, I am sure, hurt pride. My self-image has been severely dented. Even though I have not been playing, my standing as “a good chess player” has been an important element in my sense of identity. I want it back.
But I have begun to see that something deeper is also at work - my need for clear structure, aims and, above all else, outcomes. This is a need that I didn’t realise I had.
I have begun to see that for years part of me may have been struggling with the ill-defined nature of the spiritual life. The results (especially the benefits) of all the practice, effort, soul-searching and life-changing decisions can be difficult to see. Indeed, it may not be at all clear what “positive results” might look like.
And when outcomes are not clear, it can be difficult sometimes to find the energy and motivation to keep going.
It is sometimes only in looking back that any objective measure of “progress” can been seen. Or perhaps from an unexpected comment by an old acquaintance about how much more peaceful we now are, or how well we now listen.
But perhaps deep down I want more than this. I want to clearly see what is happening and be able to respond accordingly. I suppose I want to be in control.
The truth, however, is that walking the spiritual path is an act of faith, in response to a deep inner impulse that cannot be denied. And it may well be that the impulse is not even mine, but is a response to a call from a level of reality immeasurably deeper than “me”.
Viewed this way, the desire to be in control looks a bit silly.
For much of the time we must be content with a subjective, rather than objective, sense of progress. We have to keep walking the path, content for most of the time with an intuitive sense that we are going in the right direction, rather than seeking to mark off stages of the journey on some kind of spiritual map.
I wonder also whether I have been struggling with the spiritual focus on the “now”. Perhaps part of my mind wants a plan, full of aims and objectives to which to give itself. Being “in the present” is all well and good, but without a plan for the future the reservoir of creative energy within each of us can begin to stagnate
My experience with the chess tournament suggests, much to my surprise, that I may have been struggling with all of this. It has left a suspicion that my desire to return to chess playing is in part a rebellion against the unplanned, amorphous, faith-demanding mysteriousness of the spiritual life.
Perhaps chess has become a symbol for my mind of this sense of discomfort.
The chess board is a small, closed world of systematic rules and consequences. It has objective structure and outcomes. What has occurred can be clearly seen and firm plans for improvement laid for the future. It provides its own focus and way forward.
I may not enjoy chess, but at least I know what is happening and where I should be aiming for. It is very tempting to live once more in such a small, predictable “world” rather than in the limitless universe of deep spiritual mystery.
Of course, I could always try to reduce the Mystery to the spiritual equivalence of chess. I could embrace a religious belief system of absolute truths, ethics and authority (probably based on a book) with a clear reward system of predictable consequences for “good” and “bad” behaviour and a non-negotiable vision for the future.
Tempting as this sounds, however, it would not work - I cannot live a lie. Chess in its own terms is true – it is a small, closed system of immutable laws. But I know that the awesome ineffability of existence cannot be reduced to this, easier though it may seem to make life.
So I must keep faithfully walking into the dazzling darkness, trusting my inner compass, knowing that for reasons I can never really understand I can do no other.
But I must also keep questioning everything that happens.